Between 54-87% of retail CFD accounts lose money. Based on 69 brokers who display this data.

BrokerDNA

The BROKERDNA score tells you, overall, how reputable, suitable, and affordable a broker is compared to other brokers.

This score is algorithmically-generated based on 31 factors. Neither our team, nor the brokers featured on our site, are able to change this without changing their service offering. Learn more here.

CMC Markets
9 /10

The BROKERDNA score tells you, overall, how reputable, suitable, and affordable a broker is compared to other brokers.

This score is algorithmically-generated based on 31 factors. Neither our team, nor the brokers featured on our site, are able to change this without changing their service offering. Learn more here.

VISIT CMC MARKETS
City Index
9.2 /10

The BROKERDNA score tells you, overall, how reputable, suitable, and affordable a broker is compared to other brokers.

This score is algorithmically-generated based on 31 factors. Neither our team, nor the brokers featured on our site, are able to change this without changing their service offering. Learn more here.

VISIT CITY INDEX
XTB
10 /10

The BROKERDNA score tells you, overall, how reputable, suitable, and affordable a broker is compared to other brokers.

This score is algorithmically-generated based on 31 factors. Neither our team, nor the brokers featured on our site, are able to change this without changing their service offering. Learn more here.

VISIT XTB
About

CMC Markets is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, NFA and ACN. CMC Markets have provided Forex trading services since 1989.

City Index is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. City Index have provided Forex trading services since 1983.

XTB is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. XTB have provided Forex, CFD, and social trading services since 2002.

Why choose them?
  • Yes Over 29 years in business
  • Yes Segregates clients funds
  • Yes Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority
  • Yes Over 35 years in business
  • Yes Segregates clients funds
  • Yes Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority, ASIC and MAS
  • Yes Over 16 years in business
  • Yes Segregates clients funds
  • Yes Regulated by Financial Conduct Authority, KNF, and CMB.
Headquarters London, UK London, UK Level 34, One Canada Square, Canary Wharf, E14 5AA, London, UK

TRADING SERVICES OFFERED

Spot Forex Yes Yes Yes
Forex (CFD) Yes Yes Yes
CFD Yes Yes Yes
Spread Betting Yes Yes No
Social Trading No No No
MARKETS & INSTRUMENTS
Forex (currency pairs) 32 84 48
Commodities Offered 0 26 21
Stocks Offered 9000 4500 1606
Bitcoin No Yes Yes
Majors Yes Yes Yes
Indices Yes Yes Yes
US Stocks Yes Yes Yes
Penny stocks No Yes Yes
Energies Yes Yes Yes
Metals Yes Yes Yes
Agriculturals Yes Yes Yes
FTSE No Yes Yes
Dow Jones No Yes Yes
Dax Yes Yes Yes
Nikkei No Yes Yes
ETFs No Yes Yes
IPO No No Yes
See all instruments

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

See all instruments

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

See all instruments

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

PLATFORM & FEATURES

See the platforms and features offered by each broker

Screenshot image image image
MT4 No Yes Yes
MT5 No No No
MT4 Mac No No Yes
WebTrader Yes Yes Yes
Mirror Trader No No Yes
ZuluTrade No No No
Sirix No No No
cTrader No No No
PAMM Yes Yes No
Custom Platforms Next Generation AT Pro, Advantage Web Xstation5

APPS

iOS image Yes Yes Yes
Android image Yes Yes Yes
Windows image No Yes Yes
Available Languages

English, German, French, Polish, Spanish, Swedish, Italian, and Norwegian

English, Spanish, German, Arabic, Polish, and Chinese

English, Spanish, Czech, Chinese, German, French, Italian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Slovenian, Turkish, Arabic, and Russian.

See platform & features

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

See platform & features

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

See platform & features

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

ACCOUNT INFORMATION

From micro accounts to ECN accounts, compare the accounts offered by CMC Markets and City Index

Demo account Yes Yes Yes
Mini account Yes Yes Yes
Micro account No Yes Yes
Standard account Yes Yes Yes
ECN Account No No No
Islamic account No No Yes
Zero spread account No No No
VIP account No Yes Yes
Fixed spreads No Yes Yes
Variable spreads Yes Yes Yes
See account options

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

See account options

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

See account options

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

TRADING CONDITIONS

Scalping Yes No Yes
Hedging Yes Yes Yes
Expert advisors (EAs) No Yes Yes
Virtual private server No No No
Direct market access No No Yes
STP broker No Yes Yes
Market maker Yes Yes Yes
Min trade Varies 1 Lot 0.01 Lot
Max trade Varies Varies 100 Lot
Min deposit $200 $25 $1

RISK MANAGEMENT

Stop losses Yes Yes Yes
Limit orders Yes Yes Yes
One-click trading Yes Yes Yes
Trailing stops Yes Yes Yes
Price alerts Yes Yes Yes
Signal trading Yes Yes Yes

FUNDING METHODS

Credit card Yes Yes Yes
Bank transfer Yes Yes Yes
Standard account Yes Yes Yes
Paypal No No Yes
Neteller No No Yes
Skrill No No Yes
Payment processing time 1-5 business days 2-3 business days Same day if requested before 1PM
Withdrawal processing time 1-2 business days 2-3 business days Same day if requested before 1PM
See all funding options

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

See all funding options

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

See all funding options

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

DETAILED INFO

Excluded countries US, CF, TD, CG, CI, CU, GN, ER, FR, GW, HT, IR, IQ, KR, LB, LR, LY, MM, NZ, NG, SL, SO, SD, SY, TM, UZ, VE, EH, YE, ZW, CA, CV, KY, CM, KH, BI, BF, CL, CN, CX, CC, CO, GL, GU, GT, HN, HK, IN, ID, IL, JM, JP, JO, KZ, KW, KG, LA, LV, MG, MY, MV, MU, MR, MX, FM, MN, MS, MZ, NA, NP, PK, PA, PY, PH, PE, PN, RW, LC, WS, SA, LK, SZ, TW, TZ, TH, TT, TN, UG, AE, VI, UM, ZM, VN, TV, KE, KP, GH, FJ, SV, EC, DO, DJ, BR, BT, BD, BH, BB, AZ, AR US, CF, TD, CG, CI, CU, GN, ER, FR, GW, HT, IR, IQ, KR, LB, LR, LY, MM, NZ, NG, SL, SO, SD, SY, TM, UZ, VE, EH, YE, ZW, CA, CV, KY, CM, KH, BI, BF, CL, CN, CX, CC, CO, GL, GU, GT, HN, HK, IN, ID, IL, JM, JP, JO, KZ, KW, KG, LA, LV, MG, MY, MV, MU, MR, MX, FM, MN, MS, MZ, NA, NP, PK, PA, PY, PH, PE, PN, RW, LC, WS, SA, LK, SZ, TW, TZ, TH, TT, TN, UG, AE, VI, UM, ZM, VN, TV, KE, KP, GH, FJ, SV, EC, DO, DJ, BR, BT, BD, BH, BB, AZ, AR US,IN,PK,BD,IQ,IR,IL,AF,AU,CA
Contact email Send Email Send Email Send Email
Phone number +1300 303 888 0845 355 0801 44 2036953085
Live Chat No Yes Yes
Website https://www.cmcmarkets.com www.cityindex.co.uk www.xtb.com
Spreads:
EUR/USD (Average: 0.7 pips) 0.7 pips + $0.00 0.7 pips 0.1 pips
GBP/USD (Average: 1.1 pips) 0.9 pips + $0.00 1.7 pips 0.1 pips
USD/JPY (Average: 1.1 pips) 0.7 pips + $0.00 0.6 pips 0.1 pips
AUD/USD (Average: 0.8 pips) 0.9 pips + $0.00 0.6 pips 0.2 pips
USD/CHF (Average: 2.3 pips) 1.5 pips + $0.00 2.3 pips 0.2 pips
USD/CAD (Average: 2.9 pips) 1.7 pips + $0.00 0.5 pips 0.3 pips
NZD/USD (Average: 3.6 pips) 2.0 pips + $0.00 2.8 pips 0.3 pips
EUR/GBP (Average: 2.4 pips) 1.1 pips + $0.00 0.5 pips 0.1 pips
View all spreads

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

View all spreads

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

View all spreads

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

FEES

Inactivity Fee Yes Yes No
Commission Yes, 0.10% 0.0015 Yes
Deposit Fee Varies Varies No
Withdrawal Fee Varies Varies No
View All Fees

78% of retail investor accounts lose money when spread betting and/or trading CFDs with this provider

View All Fees

70% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider

View All Fees

76% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.

Featured In Best CFD Brokers
Best Spread Betting Brokers
Best Brokers For Stocks
Best Brokers For Indices
Best FCA Regulated Brokers
Best Day Trading Brokers
Best Brokers For Commodities
Best Brokers For Copper
Best DAX Brokers
Best FCA Regulated Brokers
Best Brokers That Accept PayPal
Best Forex Islamic Accounts
Best Litecoin Brokers
Best Brokers For Gold
Best Brokers For Copper
Last update

All information collected from https://www.cmcmarkets.com. Last updated on 01/11/2019.

All information collected from www.cityindex.co.uk. Last updated on 01/11/2019.

All information collected from www.xtb.com. Last updated on 01/11/2019.

Company

CMC Markets were founded in 1989 and are one of the leading CFD and spread betting providers. The main differentiator about CMC Markets is their bespoke award-winning trading platform. CMC Markets also offer very reasonable spreads and offer a wide range of instruments.

For more information about trading with CMC Markets, we have put together an indepth CMC Markets review with all the pros and cons about this broker.

Since establishing themselves as one of the first spread betting providers in the UK. , City Index have grown to a global company in over 50 countries completing over two million trades every month. City Index provide some of the most competitive spreads across thousands of markets including indices, shares, currencies, commodities and many more.

City Index have continued to innovate and were the first to provide a downloadable Android and iPhone app for spread betting and CFD trading and with over 30 years experience in the industry, you know you can trust Cityindex to handle your trades.

For more information about trading with City Index, we have put together an indepth City Index review with some of the pros and cons about this broker.

XTB provides hyper fast execution and facilitates seminars with external professional traders, providing personalised education depending on your individual circumstances.

XTB operates with two factors in mind; to provide traders with the fastest execution speeds and to be the most transparent broker on the market, which is reflected by the services and products they provide.

XTB also have a dedicated education area - the Trading Academy - which contains material to help you become a better trader, including video tutorials, trading courses, articles and much more to improve your skills at every step of your trading journey.

If you are looking for a broker that is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority and focuses on transparency, fast execution speeds and customer service, XTB is a great option.

For more information about trading with XTB, we have put together an in-depth XTB review covering the pros and cons of this broker.

Popular comparisons

Popular comparisons feat. CMC Markets

CMC Markets Alternatives

ETX Capital vs CMC Markets
Core Spreads vs CMC Markets
Plus500 vs CMC Markets
IG vs CMC Markets
Avatrade vs CMC Markets

Popular comparisons feat. City Index

City Index Alternatives

City Index vs IG
City Index vs CMC Markets
City Index vs Plus500
City Index vs Forex.com
City Index vs IC Markets

Popular comparisons feat. XTB

XTB Alternatives

XTB vs IG
XTB vs Plus500
XTB vs eToro
XTB vs Interactive Brokers
XTB vs XM

CMC Markets or City Index?

Accepts Scalping or access to MT4?

If you’re a trader looking for a broker that allows scalping as a trading strategy, CMC Markets may be the better option. However, if you want a broker that offers MetaTrader4 as a trading platform, City Index may be more suitable.

Which broker is more reliable?

You can determine a broker’s reliability & trustworthiness by looking at eight factors:

  • Who are they regulated by?
  • How long have they been around for?
  • Do they hold your money in a separate bank account?
  • Do they use reputable “tier-1” banks like Barclays, Goldman Sachs or HSBC?
  • Have they been fined or penalised in the last five years?
  • The popularity of their service/website
  • Are they publicly listed?
  • Where are they located?

Based on these eight factors, we consider CMC Markets to be the more reliable broker. We’ve broken down why below:

Who are they regulated by?

CMC Markets is regulated by Financial Conduct Authority, while City Index is regulated by Financial Conduct Authority, ASIC and MAS.

As the Financial Conduct Authority are one of the most stringent regulators in the world, both CMC Markets and City Index will have very strict guidelines to follow to ensure they protect their retail trader clients.

XTB are also regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

How long have they been around for?

If a broker has been around for a long period of time, they’re likely to be more reliable (in comparison, most scam brokers only exist for several years before they disappear).

This also suggests that a broker has good risk management processes that have prevented them being caught out by major financial events, as was the case with Alpari UK going bust when they were there was a policy reversal of capping the Swiss Franc against the Euro.

CMC Markets has been around for 30 years, while City Index have been around for 36 years. Our third alternative broker, XTB, have been around for 17 years.

Do they hold your money in a separate bank account?

You wouldn’t want your broker paying their staff out of the same bank account account that you’re depositing your trading funds into, would you?

Fortunately, all regulated brokers must use segregated bank accounts to hold client money. This is one of the reasons why we only feature regulated brokers here on BrokerNotes.

All three brokers above will hold your money in a separate bank account.

Do they use reputable “tier-1” banks like Barclays, Goldman Sachs or HSBC?

Most tier-1 banks like Barclays and HSBC have been around for over 100 years and manage trillions of dollars of assets, proving that they have stood the test of time.

Both CMC Markets and City Index use tier one banks, but we are not sure of which bank specifically.

Have they been fined or penalised in the last five years?

If a broker has been penalised by a regulator in the past five years, it may mean that they were caught doing something they shouldn’t be doing - which may be of concern to you as an end client.

We’re not aware of any penalties or fines imposed by regulators on CMC Markets or City Index in the past five years.

How popular is their service/website?

While not always the case, the number of traders a broker has can be a good metric for understanding how reputable a brokers is.

City Index is more popular with over 140,000 traders.

Are they publicly listed?

Companies that are publicly listed on a stock exchange tend to be considered more reputable as they will be required to disclose their financials, and aspects of their operations, to the public.

CMC Markets is a publicly listed company, while on the other hand City Index is still a privately owned company.

Where are they located?

Most reputable brokers tend to be headquartered in a major capital city or a financial hub such as Cyprus.

Both CMC Markets and City Index are based in London, UK .

Do they offer the features you need?

Assuming the brokers you’re choosing between are reputable, the next point to consider is whether they offer all of the features you require to trade.

This can be broken down into three categories:

  • Services & instruments
  • Platforms & account types
  • Trading features, risk management tools & funding methods

Services and Instruments

If you’re looking to trade currency pairs, both CMC Markets and City Index offer forex trading. City Index have a slightly larger variety of currency pairs with 84 pairs, compared to 32 offered by CMC Markets. Also, if you’re looking to trade cryptocurrencies, City Index offers a handful of cryptocurrency CFDs to trade, including Bitcoin, Ethereum and Ripple.

Both CMC Markets and City Index allow you to trade commodities like gold, silver and crude oil.

Platforms & Account Types

In addition to the platform, you’ll also want to ensure that the broker you choose offers the account type best suited to your needs. City Index, for example, offer a mini account, standard account and VIP account.

Trading features, risk management tools & funding methods

If you have a certain trading style (e.g. scalping, hedging, or using EAs), you’ll want to double check that the broker you choose allows this, as not all of them do.

CMC Markets does allow scalping and hedging. While City Index does not allow scalping but does allow hedging. You can't trade with EAs (expert advisors) on CMC Markets but you can trade EAs (expert advisors) with City Index.

In terms of risk management tools, neither CMC Markets or City Index offers negative balance protection. Negative balance protection prevents you owing your broker more than you’ve deposited.

CMC Markets also offer stop losses, limit orders, and price alerts to help you automate aspects of your trading strategy.

CMC Markets accept Payoneer while City Index accept Payoneer.

Are they affordable for what you need?

Comparing the fee structures of different brokers can be a minefield at times. The important thing to consider is what the spreads & fees are on the specific instruments and account type that you will be using.

For trading EUR/USD, CMC Markets charges 0.70 points, while City Index charges 0.50 points. Therefore, City Index is the more affordable for this instrument. If you want to compare their spreads across more instruments, You can jump back up to our comparison of their currency pair & indice spreads above.

Another consideration is whether or not your broker charges inactivity, deposit/withdrawal fees, or commissions on trades. If you’re a frequent trader, inactivity fees are unlikely to be an issue.

The Verdict: CMC Markets or City Index?

There’s no such thing as a perfect broker, but some are going to be a better fit for you than others.

Objectively, CMC Markets is more reliable based on our criteria above. CMC Markets has a wider range of instruments to trade. City Index offer lower spreads on popular forex instruments like EUR/USD and are used by more traders.

Both brokers offer demo accounts, allowing you to test their platforms to see which is suitable for you. You can test drive their demos using the links below:

Finally, if you’re really not sure you can always use our free tool (takes 15 seconds) that will help you find a suitable broker based on your precise requirements here.